NPS Secretary Order 3431  ·  Public Comment Analysis

National park visitors flooded the NPS “snitch form”… but not to snitch on parks

The Trump administration posted QR codes at national parks asking visitors to report signs that “disparage” American history. An analysis of 35,700 submitted comments shows that less than 1% actually used those forms as intended.

Center for Western Priorities  ·  Data: NPS SO-3431 public comments released via FOIA  ·  June 2025–January 2026  ·  475 park units

In March 2025, President Trump signed an executive order directing federal agencies to review how American history is presented at National Park Service sites, with a mandate to eliminate content that “inappropriately disparages Americans past or living.” Interior Secretary Doug Burgum followed with Secretarial Order 3431, which directed NPS staff to post QR code signs at every park unit asking visitors to report interpretive content that failed to “emphasize the beauty, grandeur, and abundance of landscapes and other natural features.”

The move drew immediate criticism from historians, conservation groups, and the general public who identified it as a mechanism to erase or whitewash the difficult parts of American history, including exhibits on slavery, Indigenous displacement, Japanese American incarceration, and climate change. Reports of signs and exhibits being flagged or removed soon followed at dozens of parks and historic sites.

In May 2026, the Department of the Interior released 35,700 comments submitted through the QR code system in response to a FOIA request by KOAA News 5. The Center for Western Priorities analyzed the full dataset to understand how the public actually used the form and found that almost no one used it as the Trump administration intended. Comments flooded in and included mostly general support for protecting national parks, arguments for the preservation of history, general opposition to the secretarial order and the form itself, reviews of visits to national parks, opposition to Trump and Burgum, and a wide array of jokes and trolling. But a negligible amount of comments, about 0.1 percent, actually reported signage or supported the removal of signage. The American people certainly took advantage of this public input process and made their voices heard, and they are vehemently opposed to attempts to erase history and censor national parks.

Comments that reported signs

0.1%
Fewer than 1 in 800 comments flagged a sign for removal, the form’s stated purpose
That’s 47 comments out of 35,700 submitted across 475 national park units between June 2025 and January 2026.

Support for public lands and opposition to the sign removal order were near-unanimous, at 99.9 percent. Out of the 35,700 total submissions, CWP's analysis identified just 47 comments that flagged a sign for removal or showed broad support for the removal of signs as the order intended. Of those 47, only 14 used the form in the way the Trump administration likely intended — calling for removal of content they considered too biased toward Indigenous peoples, people of color, climate science, or LGBTQ history. 20 used the form to demand more inclusive history and better representation in signage, such as noting that a historical marker used a racial slur. Several seemed to be satirical, and some flagged signs for being poorly written or having factual inaccuracies.

It should be noted that 13,308 comments were coordinated form letters from advocacy campaigns submitted across hundreds of parks. Every single form letter campaign was in opposition to the sign-removal order. Even setting those aside and looking only at the 22,392 original comments, just 0.2 percent flagged a specific sign or supported sign removal. The remaining 99.8% defended historical accuracy, expressed support for the NPS, or pushed back against the order.

What the 47 flagged comments actually said

Of comments that used the form to flag or support removal of signage

35,700
Total comments submitted
475
Park units represented
13,308
Coordinated form letters (all in opposition)
47
Flagged signage or supported removal (0.1%)

Comment topics

Comments by category

Toggle to show original comments alongside the coordinated template campaigns. Templates appear in lighter shades as a separate group.

Comments by state

Breakdown by state

Percentages of each state’s total comments. Hover over any state for a park-by-park breakdown.

Less
More Gray = no data

Selected comments

A cross-section of what visitors actually submitted

Comments are reproduced verbatim from the dataset.

Methodology

Data source

The 35,700-row dataset was released May 22, 2026 by the Department of the Interior in response to a FOIA request filed by KOAA News 5. The full dataset is available via the National Park Service FOIA request site. CWP conducted its own analysis with the assistance of Claude AI and a manual verification process.

On coordinated template comments

13,308 submissions were identified as coordinated campaigns — verbatim or near-verbatim texts submitted across hundreds of parks. All identified campaigns were in opposition to the sign-removal order. These are displayed separately in the chart above and excluded from the by-state breakdown. The 0.1% figure for flagged comments is calculated against the full 35,700-comment total.

Classification approach

Each original comment was classified using a rule-based pattern-matching script written in Python, developed with the assistance of Claude AI and verified by CWP staff. The classifier first identifies coordinated template campaigns, then assigns the remaining ~22,400 original comments to one of seven categories based on keyword and phrase matching. The full annotated script is available on CWP’s GitHub.

Category definitions

Accuracy and verification

There is ambiguity in many of the comments, which address multiple categories, and the final classification is subjective. A random sample of 120 comments (20 per category) was reviewed by CWP staff across six rounds of iterative verification, with an overall category accuracy rate of approximately 89%. Per-category accuracy was lowest in the general opposition category, reflecting its broad catch-all design, and does not affect the headline finding. The “flagged signage or supported removal” category was verified through a complete manual review by CWP staff of all AI-categorized entries.

State mapping

Park names were matched to states using a lookup table covering approximately 75% of submissions. The remainder did not have a park name associated with them or the park name could not be matched to a state.